What Is The Difference Between The Processing Methods Of 347 Stainless Steel And 316l Stainless Steel In Cnc Machining?

What is the difference between the processing methods of 347 stainless steel and 316L stainless steel in CNC machining?

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Did you know that stainless steel is one of the most widely used materials in the world? According to a report published by the International Stainless Steel Forum (ISSF), global stainless steel production reached approximately 52 million tons in 2022 alone. Among the numerous grades available, 347 and 316L stainless steel stand out due to their unique properties and versatile applications.

This blog aims to delve into the intricacies of 347 and 316L stainless steel, particularly focusing on how their processing methods differ in CNC machining. With an increasing number of industries adopting advanced manufacturing techniques, understanding these differences is vital for engineers, manufacturers, and designers alike.

Overview of Stainless Steel Types

  • to Stainless Steel
  • Stainless steel is known for its excellent corrosion resistance, strength, and versatility. It’s an alloy primarily composed of iron, chrom, and a minimum of 10.5% chromium. The chromium content forms a passive layer of chromium oxide on the surface, preventing further corrosion.

  • Common Types of Stainless Steel
  • While many grades exist, stainless steels can be broadly categorized into three families:

  • Austenitic: These are non-magnetic and include common grades like 304 and
  • They offer excellent corrosion resistance and good formability.
  • Ferritic: This family includes grades like 430 and
  • Ferritic steels are magnetic and generally show good resistance to corrosion.
  • Martensitic: Examples include 410 and 420 grades, known for their hardness and strength. However, they are less resistant to corrosion than austenitic varieties.
  • Specifics of 347 and 316L Stainless Steel
  • 347 Stainless Steel:

    347 stainless steel is an austenitic alloy which contains niobium and tantalum as stabilizing agents that prevent grain boundary carbide precipitation. Its high temperature strength and excellent oxidation resistance make it suitable for applications in environments subjected to high temperatures.

    316L Stainless Steel:

    316L is another austenitic stainless steel known for its low carbon content, making it highly resistant to corrosion – particularly pitting and crevice corrosion. The addition of molybdenum enhances its resistance to harsh chemicals, making it an ideal choice for marine and chemical industries.

    Differences in Processing Methods

  • Chemical Composition and Its Impact on Machinability
  • 347 Stainless Steel:
  • Composition: The alloying elements, particularly niobium, enhance high-temperature strength but may also require specific tool materials for machining.
  • Machinability: 347 has a relatively lower machinability index compared to 316L due to its toughness and heat treatment requirements.
  • 316L Stainless Steel:
  • Composition: The lower carbon content contributes to better machinability and weldability.
  • Machinability: 316L is easier to machine, but its work-hardening characteristics can lead to tool wear if not considered during processing.
  • CNC Machining Techniques
  • A. Cutting Tools

  • 347 Stainless Steel: Due to its hardness, tools made of carbide or high-speed steel are preferable. Coated tools may increase efficiency by reducing friction and wear.
  • 316L Stainless Steel: Due to its superior machinability, standard carbide tools can be used effectively. Coolant usage is crucial to minimize heat buildup and prolong tool life.
  • B. Machining Parameters

  • Feed Rate and Speed:
  • For 347, a lower feed rate and slower speed are often required to prevent work-hardening and avoid tool failure.
  • For 316L, higher cutting speeds can be employed, but operators should be cautious about chip formation and heat generation.
  • Cooling Methods:
  • Both materials benefit from proper coolant application, but 347 may require more aggressive cooling to remove heat generated through cutting.
  • Post-Processing Techniques
  • 347 Stainless Steel:
  • After machining, components often require heat treatment to relieve stresses, particularly if they are subjected to high temperatures post-manufacturing.
  • 316L Stainless Steel:
  • Typically requires less extensive post-processing due to its lower carbon content, making it more stable and less likely to warp during machining.
  • Surface Finishing and Treatment
  • 347 Stainless Steel:
  • What Is The Difference Between The Processing Methods Of 347 Stainless Steel And 316l Stainless Steel In Cnc Machining?
  • Achieving a smooth finish might require additional steps like grinding or polishing, particularly if the part is to be used in high-heat applications.
  • 316L Stainless Steel:
  • It can achieve excellent surface finishes relatively easily due to its raccessibility and stability during machining.
  • Advantages and Disadvantages

    | Criteria | 347 Stainless Steel | 316L Stainless Steel |

    |—————————–|—————————————–|——————————————-|

    | Corrosion Resistance | High at elevated temperatures | Excellent in various environments |

    | Machinability | More challenging, requires specific tools | Easier to machine |

    | Cost | Generally higher due to alloying elements | Moderately priced, widely available |

    | Temperature Tolerance | Superior for high-heat applications | Suitable for moderate temperatures |

    | Weldability | Fair, less ideal for certain welding | Excellent, can be welded without loss of corrosion resistance |

    Applications of 347 and 316L Stainless Steel

  • Industries Utilizing 347 Stainless Steel
  • Aerospace components and exhaust systems
  • Chemical processing plants for equipment exposed to high temperatures
  • Power generation applications including gas turbines
  • Industries Utilizing 316L Stainless Steel
  • Marine industry components including vessels and fittings
  • Chemical processing, especially in the food and beverage sector
  • Medical devices, especially implants which require high corrosion resistance
  • Challenges in CNC Machining 347 and 316L Stainless Steel

  • Tool Wear and Tear
  • Both materials lead to significant tool wear, particularly due to 347’s toughness and 316L’s tendency to work-harden.

  • Chip Formation
  • 347: Chips may be stringy and difficult to manage.
  • 316L: Chips can be brittle, affecting the machining process if not managed correctly.
  • Handling Thermal Expansion
  • Both stainless steels exhibit thermal expansion properties. Thus, CNC machining parameters must be carefully monitored to accommodate this behavior, preventing dimensional inaccuracies.

    Monitoring and Quality Control

  • In-Process Monitoring
  • Utilizing tools like in-process measurement and automated inspections can markedly improve the machining process and final product quality.

  • Final Inspection
  • Post-machining, both materials should be inspected rigorously. Testing through non-destructive techniques can ensure that components meet stringent industry standards.

  • Documenting Processing Conditions
  • Maintaining a record of all the parameters can be invaluable for future projects, especially when working with complex materials like 347 and 316L stainless steel.

    The differences between processing methods for 347 and 316L stainless steel in CNC machining are critical knowledge for any manufacturing operation aiming to maximize efficiency and product quality. Both materials come with unique characteristics that require tailored approaches in machining, tooling, and post-processing.

    Understanding these distinctions not only enhances the capabilities of engineers and machinists but also assists them in making informed choices based on application requirements. Whether it’s in aerospace, chemical processing, or medical manufacturing, recognizing the fundamental differences between these stainless steel types can lead to optimized processes and superior end-products.

    As we move further into an era of advanced manufacturing, it’s worth investing time and resources into mastering these techniques. The ability to choose the right material and the right processes enables manufacturers to push boundaries and cater to evolving industry demands.

    Ultimately, this blog illustrates the importance of understanding the specifics of these stainless steel grades to ensure successful outcomes in CNC machining. So, next time you encounter a machining project involving 347 or 316L stainless steel, remember the insights shared here and the critical role they play in the larger manufacturing landscape.